Developments such as the US’ deep recession, Federal Bank rate hikes, European Union uncertainties and Russia-Ukraine war are bleeding the stock markets of Rs 2.71 lakh crore in past eight months, posing a big challenge to the Indian economy risking public deposits.
The warning is clear: If the western economies slip into a recession, the Indian economy will need to face an additional challenge. It’s exports prospects can be severely hit. “This is an anticipated outcome of their policy response of raising interest rates to manage the unprecedented inflation levels that they are currently experiencing,” Ernst and Young explains in its recent update.
The risk of the US economy tumbling into recession over the next year has doubled following the Federal Reserve’s 75 basis-point interest-rate hike last week, says Goldman Sachs. In a note it says that the chance of a recession hitting in the next 12 months has risen from 15 per cent before the rate hike, to 30 per cent as of this week.
As the economy slumps and the interest rates are hiked, foreign portfolio investors (FPI) are moving their investments back to the US. Heavy outflows of FPI money from India in the last one year exceed that during the global financial crisis (GFC) of 2008, analysts at ICICI Securities say. The ongoing FPI selling in Indian equities is turning out to be the highest selling spree since the global financial crisis (GFC) of 2008 at $36 billion against $28 billion during the GFC. However, inflows from domestic institutional investors into shaky market have been constant, while benchmark indices are down just around 10 per cent compared to more than 50 per cent in 2008.
The sell-off that began in August, 2021 and with a brief lull in September continues since October. The FPI pull-out has hit the rupee, with its exchange rate against the dollar falling to Rs 78.18 despite heavy intervention by the Reserve Bank of India.
Bankruptcy in the Euro region is deeper than explained. The latest voyage of the world’s biggest unfinished cruiser to the ship-breaking yard due to lack of a buyer is a testimony that the malaise is deeper. The European economy is getting into the throes of crisis with clogging of gas supplies from Russia, an expected food crisis and wrecking of its growth and economy for just siding with NATO. The US has yet not found a counter to checkmate Russia except giving some arms to Ukraine.
India, despite being a friend of both the US and Russia, is unable to save itself from the hazards despite maintaining a balance. It is singed by high global inflation, higher domestic inflation, high debt, falling rupee vis-a-vis the dollar. India’s external debt rises $11.5 billion in October-December 2021 to stand at $614.9 billion at the end of the quarter, according to data released by the Ministry of Finance on March 31. The IMF has issued a warning. It says external debt, by supplementing domestic savings, can help countries grow faster. But a large stock of external debt can potentially create vulnerabilities and dent growth prospects. Since the onset of the pandemic, many countries have expanded public spending to support the recovery, which has led to a build-up of their external debt. In other words, it warns to check external debt in particular.
The total external debt, which fell below the pre-crisis levels in the immediate aftermath of the pandemic lockdown, crossed the pre-pandemic levels as at end-December 2020 and commercial borrowings crossing the pre-pandemic levels as at end September 2021 and short-term trade credit crossing the pre-pandemic levels as at end-December 2021, says the RBI.
As India aims at higher, sustainable and inclusive growth, the RBI warns of keeping external debt flows within the estimated threshold limit for preserving overall macro-stability to ward off external vulnerability. It’s a stern warning, more so as savings is also not growing to meet the critical demands.
The FPI investment is not considered staple investment. But it is a kind of hedge against external borrowings, forex reserves as also the need to maintain rupee stability. The majority of the external debt is private. General government external debt stood at $131.4 billion as on December 31, down from $132.0 billion as at the end of September 2021. Non-government commercial external debt, meanwhile, rose to $483.6 billion, 36.8 per cent from $471.4 billion. The official borrowings are from international institutions on soft terms with the lowest risks. During fiscal 2021-22, India borrowed the most from the International Bank for Reconstruction and Development at Rs 22,362 crore, followed by Asian Development Bank at Rs 16802 crore and the Government of Japan at Rs 9835 crore.
During the week ending February 25, India’s foreign currency assets declined by $2.22 billion. Since then much more was lost in managing the rupee and the external sector. The rupee remains under pressure. This is a clear call for severe caution. The void of the FPIs is being filled up by domestic institutional investors (DIIs), led by the LIC, mutual funds and insurance companies. They are absorbing most of the FPI sales to keep the stock market maintain a semblance but it is an artificial support for virtually subsidising the domestic companies, whose valuations are on an apparent roll. In other words, public money is being pumped into shaky private operations further debilitating the public institutions.
The institutions are supposed to take independent decisions. But this kind of operations pushing them into risky operations is questionable. Most of these organisations, now particularly LIC, are in high risk of losing people’s deposits. The RBI, SEBI and other regulators need to step in to check such deals and purchases, as the market value of many corporates with high ECBs as also domestic borrowings are suspect.
What appears as an innocuous withdrawal of some foreign companies is causing a deep sense of hurt. This calls for a decision at the level of top regulators as also the Ministry of Finance to check the quality of investments being made in the risky assets. Stocks prices are mostly notional and speculative – based on the premise that it would have gains. Since 1992, the innumerable crashes or scams were based on these premises. Severe caution is needed at this hour as even an innocuous repeat of a failure can shear the Indian economy of billions, if not trillions.
What looks like a US or Euro recession, if not treaded cautiously, could have deleterious effect. Remember the adage ‘a stitch in time saves nine’. — INFA
